Select location
Membership information
0800 561 9000
Medicolegal advice
0800 561 9090
Refine my search

Specimen mix-up

Post date: 01/11/2005 | Time to read article: 1 mins

The information within this article was correct at the time of publishing. Last updated 14/11/2018

This case report took place five years ago in a hospital overseas. Dr A, a dermatologist, took a punch biopsy of thick skin plaques on Mr J’s knee to confirm a diagnosis of psoriasis. Mr J had recently retired from his occupation as a carpet fitter. When the laboratory reported ‘a poorly differentiated squamous cell carcinoma’, Dr A discussed the result with his colleague Dr Q – a plastic surgeon – and arranged for Mr J to see him.

Dr Q carried out a wide excision – 2cm to 3cm in diameter – of the lesion on Mr J’s knee. However, this time the histology report showed only a seborrhoeic keratosis with no evidence of malignancy.

Subsequent investigation revealed that the original specimen had been given the same number, in the lab, as a fine-needle aspirate from another patient’s lung. Dr V, the pathologist who had signed Mr J’s report, was at a loss to explain how the error had arisen and why she had not noticed the error before signing the two reports.

Although we felt that the hospital should bear some of the liability on behalf of the unknown laboratory assistant who had mislabelled the specimens, it refused to accept this argument, claiming that Dr V was solely liable because she had signed the histopathology report. The claim was settled for a sum equivalent to £35,000 (US$62,000), with almost the same again in costs.

Learning points

  • A heavy workload – Demand on clinical laboratories is intense, with heavy workloads and often poor staffing levels. But this is mitigation, not a defence. Reliable and frequently reviewed specimen management procedures are therefore essential if errors are to be avoided.
  • Learning from mistakes – The hospital should undertake a root cause analysis of this untoward incident and introduce changes to their procedures to prevent a recurrence.

Share this article

Load more reviews

You've already submitted a review for this item

New site feature tour

Introducing an improved
online experience

You'll notice a few things have changed on our website. After asking our members what they want in an online platform, we've made it easier to access our membership benefits and created a more personalised user experience.

Why not take our quick 60-second tour? We'll show you how it all works and it should only take a minute.

Take the tour Continue to site

Medicolegal advice
0800 561 9090
Membership information
0800 561 9000

Key contact details

Should you need to contact us, our phone numbers are always visible.

Personalise your search

We'll save your profession in the "I am a..." dropdown filter for next time.

Tour completed

Now you've seen all of the updated features, it's time for you to try them out.

Continue to site
Take again